| Batting Average | ||
| Name | Years | Average |
| Danny Little | 1986-89 | .411 |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | .393 |
| Derrick Manley | 2002-05 | .388 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | .380 |
| Bo Bray | 2001-04 | .378 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | .377 |
| Tavin Thompson | 2016-17 | .373 |
| J.P. Johnston | 1998-01 | .372 |
| Trey Walker | 2007-09 | .365 |
| Cory Matticola | 2005-08 | .365 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | .365 |
| Slugging Percentage | ||
| Name | Years | Percentage |
| Blake Butcher | 2016-17 | .626 |
| Danny Little | 1986-89 | .594 |
| Bo Bray | 2001-04 | .580 |
| J.P. Johnston | 1998-01 | .579 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | .577 |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | .568 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | .554 |
| Tom Darden | 1984-87 | .554 |
| Robbie Shelton | 2008-11 | .544 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | .544 |
| On-Base Percentage (Since 2000) | ||
| Name | Years | Percentage |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | .478 |
| Tavin Thompson | 2016-17 | .470 |
| Bo Bray | 2001-05 | .457 |
| Cory Matticola | 2005-08 | .450 |
| Patrick Langley | 2006-08 | .445 |
| Trey Walker | 2007-09 | .444 |
| Derrick Manley | 2002-05 | .442 |
| Rhett Mixon | 2017- | .439 |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | .435 |
| Robbie Shelton | 2008-11 | .434 |
| Cael Chatham | 2019-22 | .433 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | .433 |
| At-Bats | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 804 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 739 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 718 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 709 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 706 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | 693 |
| Casey Bell | 2014-17 | 642 |
| Bill Garrett | 1984-87 | 641 |
| Craig Chatman | 1995-98 | 639 |
| Seth Tucker | 2005-08 | 637 |
| Runs Scored | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 222 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 214 |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 210 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 179 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | 177 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-01 | 168 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 168 |
| Seth Tucker | 2005-08 | 165 |
| Cael Chatham | 2019-22 | 139 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1985-88 | 138 |
| Hits | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 316 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 273 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 267 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | 253 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 241 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 237 |
| J.P. Johnston | 1998-01 | 224 |
| Seth Tucker | 2005-08 | 221 |
| Casey Bell | 2014-17 | 212 |
| David Wilson | 1984-86 | 212 |
| Doubles | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 65 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | 51 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 50 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2021-22 | 49 |
| Casey Bell | 2014-17 | 48 |
| Seth Tucker | 2005-08 | 47 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 43 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 43 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-01 | 42 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1985-88 | 40 |
| Triples | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 22 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 20 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 18 |
| Stan Williamson | 1999-02 | 18 |
| J.P. Johnston | 1998-01 | 15 |
| Blane Swift | 2016-17 | 13 |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 11 |
| Bill Garrett | 1984-87 | 11 |
| James Poropatic | 2015-18 | 10 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-01 | 10 |
| Scott Incrocci | 1985-88 | 10 |
| Home Runs | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 43 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1985-88 | 28 |
| Tom Darden | 1984-87 | 24 |
| Danny Little | 1986-89 | 23 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-01 | 20 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 19 |
| Robbie Shelton | 2008-11 | 19 |
| Runs Batted In | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Joe Ruth | 2019- | 232 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 188 |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 184 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 166 |
| J.P. Johnston | 1998-01 | 155 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1985-88 | 146 |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 139 |
| Bo Bray | 2001-04 | 135 |
| Cael Chatham | 2019-22 | 132 |
| Casey Bell | 2014-17 | 132 |
| Walks | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Jack Layrisson | 2018-22 | 116 |
| McKinley Erves | 2018-22 | 115 |
| Tom Darden | 1984-87 | 113 |
| Rhett Mixon | 2017- | 108 |
| Craig Garner | 1991-94 | 98 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985-88 | 97 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1985-88 | 94 |
| Stevie Cottrell | 1999-01 | 91 |
| Craig McWhorter | 1984-88 | 89 |
| Cael Chatham | 2019-22 | 80 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-02 | 80 |
| Stolen Bases | ||
| Name | Years | Number |
| Michael Sims | 2005-08 | 111 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2002-05 | 95 |
| Craig Garner | 1991-94 | 74 |
| Seth Tucker | 2005-08 | 67 |
| Josh DuBose | 1998-01 | 60 |
| Travis Moore | 1994-95 | 60 |
| David Wilson | 1984-86 | 55 |
| Patrick Langley | 2006-08 | 54 |
| Derrick Manley | 2002-05 | 53 |
| Josh Shiver | 2012-13 | 41 |
