| All-Americans | ||
| Joe Ruth | D3baseball.com 1st team | 3B- 2022 |
| Joe Ruth | ABCA/Rawlings 1st team | 3B- 2022 |
| McKinley Erves | D3baseball.com 2nd team | OF- 2022 |
| McKinley Erves | ABCA/Rawlings 3rd team | OF- 2022 |
| Casey Bell | D3baseball.com 1st team | DH- 2017 |
| Ryan Broaderick | ABCA/Rawlings 2nd team | P- 2017 |
| Blake Butcher | ABCA/Rawlings 2nd team | IF- 2017 |
| Michael Sims | NCAA 1st team | IF-2008 |
| Michael Sims | D3baseball.com 2nd team | IF-2008 |
| Michael Sims | NCAA 3rd team | OF-2007 |
| Jimmy Statler | USCAA | IF-2005 |
| Tim Canady | USCAA | P-2005 |
| Titus Martin | USCAA | P-2003 |
| Derrick Manley | USCAA | OF-2003,2005 |
| Tyler Johnson | USCAA | IF-2003, 2005 |
| Bo Bray | USCAA | C-2003-04 |
| Bo Bray | NCAA 3rd team | C-2003 |
| Patrick McCarthy | USCAA | P-2002-03 |
| Josh Deyton | USCAA | OF-2002 |
| J.P. Johnston | NCAA 2nd team | DH-2001 |
| Matt Lee | NCAA Honorable Mention | OF-2000 |
| Danny Lee | NAIA Honorable Mention | IF-1989 |
| All-Conference | ||
| Curt Bonner | CCS | OF-2023 |
| Eli Folds | CCS | RP-2023 |
| Ethan Fry | CCS | SP-2023 |
| Rhett Mixon | CCS | OF-2023 |
| Edurado Peralta | CCS | SP-2023 |
| Ashton Shackelford | CCS | RP-2023 |
| David Smigelski | CCS | C-2023 |
| Jacob Brown | USA South | RP- 2022 |
| Cael Chatham | USA South | SS- 2021 |
| E.J. Churchich | USA South | DH-2019 |
| Spencer Douches | USA South | P-2019 |
| McKinley Erves | USA South | OF-2019, 21, 22 |
| Austin Fain | USA South | P-2019 |
| Richie Post | USA South | P-2019 |
| Joe Ruth | USA South | OF/3B-2019, 21, 22,23 |
| Gibson Bittner | USA South | P-2018 |
| Jack Layrisson | USA South | IF- 2018, 22 |
| Ryan Broaderick | USA South | P- 2016-17 |
| Tavin Thompson | USA South | IF- 2016-17 |
| Blake Butcher | USA South | IF- 2016-17 |
| Jonathan Fleckenstein | USA South | P-2017 |
| James Poropatic | USA South | OF-2017-18 |
| Blane Swift | USA South | OF-2017 |
| Andrew Weekley | USA South | P-2017 |
| Cain Sauls | USA South | IF-2016 |
| Chad Pigg | USA South | C- 2016 |
| Joe Pradat | USA South | IF- 2016 |
| Eric Morell | USA South | P- 2016 |
| Keith Sims | USA South | OF- 2016 |
| Casey Bell | USA South | DH- 2014, 16-17 |
| Kyle Nerbonne | USA South | C- 2014 |
| Tyler Brooks | USA South | P- 2013 |
| Josh Shiver | USA South | IF- 2013 |
| David Miller | GSAC | IF-2010-12 |
| Doug Scherer | GSAC, USA South | P-2012-13 |
| Robbie Shelton | GSAC | IF-2010 |
| Eric Heath | GSAC | OF-2009-10 |
| Ben Hudson | GSAC | UTL-2009 |
| Korey Ison | GSAC | IF-2009 |
| Trey Walker | GSAC | OF-2009 |
| Michael Sims | GSAC | IF/OF-2006-08 |
| Patrick Langley | GSAC | OF-2007-08 |
| Cory Matticola | GSAC | DH-2008 |
| Seth Tucker | GSAC | OF-2008 |
| Tim Canady | GSAC | P-2005,2007 |
| Jesse Brown | GSAC | C-2007 |
| Kevin Finnegan | GSAC | P-2006 |
| Joey Merrifield | GSAC | P-2006 |
| David Lockman | GSAC | IF-2005 |
| Jeremy Dockins | GSAC | P-2005 |
| Brad Carter | GSAC | IF-2005 |
| Nick Nelson | GSAC | C-2004-06 |
| Rod Durden | GSAC | OF-2004-05 |
| Derrick Manley | GSAC | OF-2003-05 |
| Ashley Summerlin | GSAC | IF-2003 |
| Nick Poe | GSAC | IF-2003 |
| Bucky Newell | GSAC | IF-2003 |
| Matt Mazikowski | GSAC | IF-2003 |
| Bo Bray | GSAC | C/DH-2003-04 |
| Tyler Johnson | GSAC | IF-2002-05 |
| Patrick McCarthy | GSAC | P-2002-04 |
| Mike Wood | GSAC | OF/DH-2002-03 |
| Josh Deyton | GSAC | OF-2002 |
| Titus Martin | GSAC | P-2001-03 |
| William Gurley | GSAC | P-2001,2003 |
| Stan Williamson | GSAC | IF-2001-02 |
| Matt East | GSAC | IF-2001-02 |
| Tim Garrett | GSAC | C-2001-02 |
| Josh DuBose | GSAC | OF-2001 |
| Keith Douglass | GSAC | IF-2001 |
| Stevie Cotrell | GSAC | IF-2001 |
| Matt Lee | GACC | OF-2000 |
| J.P. Johnston | GACC | DH-2000 |
| Greg Chapman | GAC | IF-1998 |
| Rusty Evans | GAC | C-1994 |
| Craig Garner | GAC | IF-1994 |
| Matt Alford | GAC | OF-1993 |
| Brian Bagwell | GAC | C-1991 |
| I.V. Bray | GAC | OF-1991 |
| Danny Little | GIAC | IF-1989 |
| Scotty Quinn | GIAC | IF-1987 |
| Tom Darden | GIAC | OF-1986-87 |
| Bill Garrett | GIAC | IF-1986 |
| Jeff Stidham | GIAC | C-1985 |
| NCAA All-Region | |
| Jacob Brown | RP- 2022 |
| Cael Chatham | IF- 2021, 2022 |
| E.J. Churchich | DH- 2021 |
| Baley Coleman | SP- 2021, 2022 |
| McKinley Erves | OF- 2021, 2022 |
| Jack Layrisson | OF- 2021, 2022 |
| Austin Fain | P- 2019 |
| Joe Ruth | OF/IF- 2019, 2021, 2022 |
| Gibson Bittner | P- 2018 |
| James Poropatic | OF- 2018 |
| Tavin Thompson | IF- 2016-17 |
| Blake Butcher | IF- 2016-17 |
| Ryan Broaderick | P- 2016-17 |
| Jonathan Fleckenstein | P- 2017 |
| Andrew Weekley | P- 2017 |
| Blane Swift | OF- 2017 |
| Casey Bell | DH- 2017 |
| Cain Sauls | IF- 2016 |
| Robbie Shelton | IF-2010 |
| Ben Hudson | UTL-2009 |
| Michael Sims | OF/IF-2007-08 |
| Patrick Langley | OF-2008 |
| Cory Maticola | DH-2008 |
| Seth Tucker | OF-2008 |
| Derrick Manley | OF-2005 |
| Tim Canady | P-2003,2005 |
| Bo Bray | C-2003 |
| Matt Mazikowski | DH-2003 |
| Tyler Johnson | IF-2002-03, 2005 |
| Mike Wood | DH-2002 |
| Titus Martin | P-2001, 2003 |
| Josh DuBose | OF-2001 |
| William Gurley | P-2001 |
| J.P. Johnston | DH-2001 |
| Matt Lee | OF-2000 |
| NAIA All-District | |
| Rusty Evans | DH-1995 |
| Matt Alford | OF-1993 |
| Danny Little | IF-1989 |
| Scotty Quinn | IF-1987 |
| Tommy Darden | OF-1986-87 |
| Player of the Year | ||
| Joe Ruth | CCS | 3B-2023 |
| Joe Ruth | ABCA/Rawlings Region 6 | 3B- 2022 |
| Joe Ruth | D3baseball.com Region 6 | 3B- 2022 |
| Joe Ruth | USA South | 3B- 2022 |
| Casey Bell | USA South | DH- 2017 |
| Blake Butcher | USA South | IF- 2016 |
| Michael Sims | GSAC | OF/IF-2008 |
| Tyler Johnson | GSAC | IF-2005 |
| Bo Bray | GSAC | C/DH-2004 |
| J.P. Johnston | GSAC | OF/DH-2001 |
| Danny Little | District 25 | IF-1989 |
| Danny Little | GIAC | IF-1989 |
| Pitcher of the Year | ||
| Austin Fain | USA South | 2019 |
| Ryan Broaderick | USA South | 2017 |
| Ryan Broaderick | ABCA/Rawlings South All-Region | 2017 |
| Titus Martin | GSAC | 2003 |
| Rookie (Freshman) of the Year | ||
| Curt Bonner | CCS | OF-2023 |
| Jack Layrisson | USA South | IF- 2018 |
| Jordan Martinec | GSAC | IF-2009 |
| Trey Walker | GSAC | OF-2007 |
| Patrick Langley | GSAC | OF/IF-2006 |
| Jimmy Statler | GSAC | IF-2005 |
| Tyler Johnson | GSAC | IF-2002 |
| Rookie Pitcher of the Year | ||
| Eduardo Peralta | CCS | 2023 |
| Jacob Brown | D3baseball.com Region 6 | 2022 |
| Richie Post | USA South | 2017 |
| Coach of the Year | |
| David Kelton | 2017,2022,2023 |
| Most Valuable Player* | |
| David Miller | 2012 |
| David Miller | 2011 |
| Robbie Shelton | 2010 |
| Ben Hudson | 2009 |
| Michael Sims | 2008 |
| Michael Sims | 2007 |
| Michael Sims | 2006 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2005 |
| Derrick Manley | 2004 |
| Tyler Johnson | 2003 |
| Stan Williamson | 2002 |
| J.P. Johnson | 2001 |
| Matt Lee | 2000 |
| Josh DuBose | 1999 |
| Craig Chatman | 1998 |
| Craig Chatman | 1997 |
| Chris Carminucci | 1996 |
| Rusty Evans | 1995 |
| Craig Garner | 1994 |
| Matt Alford | 1993 |
| Joe Jarrett | 1992 |
| Ben Moore | 1991 |
| Brian Bagwell | 1990 |
| Danny Little | 1989 |
| Eric Federspiel | 1988 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1987 |
| Tom Darden | 1986 |
| Scotty Quinn | 1985 |
| Tom Darden | 1985 |
| David Wilson | 1984 |
* Award named the Scott Markham Most Valuable Player Award beginning in 2000.
