| NFCA All-Region | Katelyn Minnihan | OF-2023 |
| CCS All-Conference | Katelyn Minnihan | 1st Team | OF-2023 |
|
CCS Rookie (Freshmen) of the Year |
Claire Chamberlin | SP-2023 |
USA South Awards
All-Conference First Team: Kalin Oglesby (2013), Alison Jiles (2015), Emily Barrs (2017)
All-Conference Second Team: Laura Webber (2013), Dani Gravett (2014, 2016), Danielle Newbern (2015), Emily Barrs (2015)
All-Conference Third Team: Courtney Beshel (2013)
All-Conference Honorable Mention: Danielle Newbern (2013), Dani Gravett (2015), Kalin Oglesby (2016)
All-Conference West Division First Team: Emily Barrs (2017, 2018), McKenzie Brunel (2017), Katelin Richardson (2017), Taylor Long (2019), Brittany Todd (2019), Reagan Gunter (2021)
All-Conference West Division Second Team: Taylor Tallant (2018), McKenzie Brunel (2018), Abbey Gardner (2021), Rebekah Hobson (2021)
| NAIA All-District | GAAC All-Conference | GAAC All-Academic | NFCA Academic All-American |
| Jennifer DeMooney, 2000 | Kelly Cline, 1997 | Brittany Adkins | Samantha Henderson, 2001 |
| Shannon Phillips, 2001 | Deanna Heard, 1997 | Laura Bullard | Kristen Lockman, 2001 |
| Aimee Thomas, 1997 | Dana Camp | Liana Thornton, 2001 | |
| Jennifer DeMooney 1998-00 | Jennifer DeMooney | ||
| Kelly Wren, 2000 | Samantha Henderson | ||
| Karey Howard | |||
| Crystal Kersey | |||
| Liana Thornton | |||
| Beth Winter | |||
| Kelly Wren |
| GSAC All-Conference | GSAC All-Freshman | GSAC All-Academic | USCAA All-American |
| Crystal Kersey, 2001 | Amy Adams, 2001 | Samantha Henderson, 2001 | Farrah McCullough, 2002-03, 05 |
| Sabrina Pace, 2001 | Hannah Goodridge, 2001 | Crystal Kersey, 2001 | Shannon Phillips, 2002-03 |
| Shannon Phillips, 2001-03 | Meredith Hilleary, 2001 | Liana Thornton, 2001 | Kelly Wren, 2002-03 |
| Liana Thornton, 2001-03 | Candi Jones, 2001 | Kelly Wren, 2001-03 | Jessica DeMooney, 2002-05 |
| Kelly Wren, 2001-03 | Larcie Lyle, 2001 | Amy Adams, 2003 | Liana Thornton, 2002-03 |
| Jessica Mears, 2003 | Shannon Phillips, 2001 | Christy Ulrich, 2003 | Kim Woodard, 2004-05 |
| Amy Adams, 2003 | Katherine Bailey, 2003 | Meredith Hilleary, 2003 | Kellee Scandrett, 2005 |
| Hannah Goodridge, 2003 | Farrah McCullough, 2003 | Larcie Lyle, 2003 | |
| Isabel Romero, 2003 | April Adams, 2003 | Katherine Bailey, 2003-05 | |
| Katherine Bailey, 2003-04 | Stephanie Bassett, 2003 | Stephanie Bailey, 2004 | |
| Farrah McCullough, 2003-05 | Mary Carden, 2003 | Stephanie Bassett, 2005-06 | |
| Jessica DeMooney, 2003-06 | Christy Kempson, 2003 | Hayley Hanson, 2005-07 | |
| Kim Woodard, 2004-07 | Kelsey McBride, 2003 | Dawn Smith, 2005-07 | |
| Kelly Scandrett, 2005-06 | Sheena McElroy, 2003 | Dicie Holland, 2006-07 | |
| Stephanie Bassett, 2006 | Tara Stanford, 2003 | Chloe Turnipseed, 2007 | |
| Dicie Holland, 2006-07 | Kellee Scandrett, 2004 | Amanda Daniel, 2007-08 | |
| Amanda Daniel, 2006-08 | Adrianne Brown, 2005 | Megan Henry, 2007-08 | |
| Valeree Williams, 2007, 2010 | Amanda Daniel, 2006 | Leah Flowers, 2008 | |
| Katie Hein, 2008-11 | Chloe Turnipseed, 2006 | Kayla Yeargin, 2008 | |
| Holly Hazelwood, 2008-10 | Kristi Underwood, 2006 | Kristi Underwood, 2008-09 | |
| Kayla Yeargin, 2009 | Leah Flowers, 2007 | Cameron Johnson, 2009 | |
| Katie Ison, 2009-11 | Jennifer Knight, 2007 | Katie Hein, 2009-11 | |
| Kristen Woodard, 2009-11 | Valeree Williams, 2007 | Danielle LaDuron, 2009-11 | |
| Shanna Brumbelow, 2010 | Kayla Yeargin, 2007 | S. Brumebelow, 2010-11 | |
| Kayla Folds 2012 | Katie Hein, 2008 | Brittany Ellisor, 2010 | |
| Erica Robinson, 2008 | Denise Van Rijst, 2010-11 | ||
| Becca Abernathy, 2009 | Valeree Williams, 2010 | ||
| Olivia McGehee, 2009 | Becca Abernathy, 2011 | ||
| Marcie Wallace, 2009 | Kayla Folds, 2011-12 | ||
| Kayla Folds, 2010 | Hanna Patterson, 2011-12 | ||
| Courtney Beshel, 2011 | Courtney Beshel, 2012 | ||
| Audrey Fortmann, 2011 | |||
| Danielle Newbern, 2012 |
GSAC Player of the Year
Jessica DeMooney, 2004-06
Kim Woodard, 2007
Holly Hazelwood, 2009 (Co-Player of the Year)
Katie Ison 2009 (Co-Player of the Year), 2010
GSAC Pitcher of the Year
Kelly Wren, 2003
Katie Hein, 2009
GSAC Freshman of the Year
Jessica DeMooney, 2003
Kim Woodard, 2004
Amanda Daniel, 2006
Valeree Williams, 2007
GSAC Coach of the Year
Jennifer Claybrook, 2003, 2006
