| NAIA All-Dist. 25 | NAIA All-Region | NAIA Academic All-American | GACC All-Academic |
| Tracy Schuster, 1992 | Tracy Schuster, 1992 | Ingrid Leek, 1991-92 | Shellye Taylor, 1998 |
| Karen Meyreth, 1998 | Nicole Hornung, 1992 | Lisa Nutile, 1998 | |
| Katie Tillison, 1998 | Lauren Hutchenson, 1992 | Elizabeth Tomko, 1998 | |
| Isabelle Romero, 1998 | Beverly Hutchenson, 1993 | ||
| Karen Goodman, 1993-94 | |||
| Christy Bradford, 1996 |
| All-GACC | All-GSAC | GSAC All-Freshman | GSAC All-Academic |
| Karen Goodman, 1992-94 | Kristen Lockman, 2001-03 | Stephanie Clark, 2004 | Kristen Lockman, 2001-03 |
| Monica Allison, 1994-95 | Kim Velosky, 2003 | Rachel Mooradian, 2004 | Melissa Smith, 2004 |
| Jennifer Smalley, 1996 | Melissa Smith, 2004 | Heather Thomas, 2005 | Angela Fadden, 2004-05 |
| Bonnie Howes, 1995, 1998 | Stephanie Clark, 2004, 2006-07 | Megan White, 2006 | Katie Rambler, 2004-05 |
| Karen Meyrath, 1998 | Sarah Wester, 2004-05 | Hannah Witherington, 2006 | Brittany Threadgill, 2004-06 |
| Katie Tillison, 1998 | Heather Thomas, 2005 | Shelley Cathcart, 2007 | Noel Winter, 2005, 2007 |
| Katie McGarvey, 1998 | Christina Cafaro, 2006 | Jennifer Eby, 2007 | Stephanie Clark, 2005-07 |
| Isabel Romero, 1998 | Brittany Threadgill, 2006 | Heather Folsom, 2007 | Akina Omae, 2007 |
| Stephanie McRae, 2007 | Allison Snider, 2007 | Marlaina Johnson, 2007-08 | |
| Shelley Cathcart, 2008, 2010 | Ashbi Alford, 2008 | Shelley Cathcart, 2008-10 | |
| Satomi Omae, 2008 | Brittany Gray, 2010 | Katie Daniel, 2008 | |
| Akina Omae, 2009 | Chelsea Totaro, 2010 | Allison Snider, 2008 | |
| Brittany Gray, 2010 | Elise Hopson, 2011 | Kylie Deese, 2009 | |
| Hope Sims, 2011 | Stephanie Fowler, 2009-10 | ||
| Shelby Stanfield, 2011 | Angie Forero, 2010-11 | ||
| Taylor Baldwin, 2011 | |||
| Kristen Bird, 2011 | |||
| Robin Dillon, 2011 | |||
| Brittany Gray, 2011 | |||
| Mendi Kallam, 2011 | |||
| Mary Robertson, 2011 | |||
| Rachael Stevenson, 2011 | |||
| Hope Sims, 2011 | |||
| Chelsea Totaro, 2011 |
| USA South All-Conference |
| Hope Sims, Honorable Mention, 2012 |
United Soccer Coaches Team Academic Award:
2009, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
GSAC Coach of the Year:
Jeff Geeter, 2003
Jim Robbins, 2010
