| NAIA All-American | NAIA All-District | All-GACC | GACC All-Academic |
| Brian Pierce, 1991 | Butch Reynolds, 1983 | Shane Norris, 1991 | Brian Pierce, 1990 |
| Warren Smith, 1996 | Gary McCallum, 1983-84 | Jason Abney, 1994 | Nick Adler, 1998 |
| Marwan Warrayant, 1983,1985 | Nat Woodrow, 1994-95 | Andy Ward, 1998 | |
| Jack Moore, 1985 | Denton Guy-Williams, 1995 | ||
| Jason Ayers, 1985 | Gary Lucero, 1995 | ||
| Jamie Camp, 1985 | Nick Adler, 1998 | ||
| Richard Johnson, 1985 | Matt Thomlinson, 1998 | ||
| Drew Uhler, 1989 | Scott Stillwell, 1998 | ||
| Shane Norris, 1991 | J.P. Moser, 1999 | ||
| John Sheffield, 1992 |
| All-GSAC | GSAC All-Freshman | GSAC All-Academic | USCAA All-American |
| Kurt Hayley, 2003 | Glenn Lewis, 2003 | Kurt Hayley, 2003 | D.J. Paradis, 2003 |
| Zak Turner, 2003-05 | Cole Zimmerman, 2003 | Zak Turner, 2004-05 | Jeremy Norman, 2003 |
| Chris Slaughter, 2004-05 | Patrick Kaney, 2004 | Jase Crenshaw, 2005 | Chris Slaughter, 2003 |
| Patrick Kaney, 2004-06 | Kojo Cole-Kesse, 2004 | Hagan Robinson, 2005 | Zak Turner, 2004 |
| Kojo Cole-Kesse, 2004-07 | Stephen Vitale, 2004 | Ryan Snider, 2005-07 | Kojo Cole-Kesse, 2004 |
| Hagan Robinson, 2005 | Pierre Arscott, 2005 | Daniel Yim, 2009-10 | Matt Hill, 2004 |
| Stephen Vitale, 2005, 2007 | Pace Callaway, 2005 | Ryan Moser, 2010 | Patrick Kaney, 2004 |
| Aristote Kamba-Pierre, 2008-09,11 | Michael Coburn, 2005 | ||
| Mohamed Sesay, 2008-09 | Matt Loria, 2005 | USCAA Academic All-American | |
| Ryan Moser, 2008, 2010 | Wes Morton, 2006 | Kurt Hayley, 2003 | |
| Cameron Williams, 2009-10 | Jamel Jackson, 2007 | Zak Turner, 2004 | |
| Brock Morris, 2011 | Mohamed Sesay, 2007 | ||
| Ben Rollins, 2007 | |||
| Nic Harris, 2008 | |||
| Josh Murphy, 2009 | |||
| Ryan Wakenigg, 2009 | |||
| Kevin Folsom, 2010 | |||
| Drew Kellum, 2010 | |||
| Donnie Palmer, 2010 |
| USA South All-Conference |
| Blake Webb, West Division First Team, Spring 2021, Fall 2021 |
| Enrique Hernandez, West Division First Team, Spring 2021, Fall 2021 |
| Alex Drazic, West Division Second Team, Spring 2021, Fall 2021 |
| Jude McEvoy, Second Team, 2018 |
| Qua Tucker, Third Team, 2018 |
| Errick Sturm, Second Team, 2017 |
| Kevin Folsom, Honorable Mention, 2012 |
Collegiate Conference of the South All-Conference
Enrique Hernandez, CCS Player of the Year, First Team, 2022
Alex Drazic, First Team, 2022
Blake Webb, First Team, 2022
Andrew Cole, Second Team, 2022
Nicholas Smiech, Second Team, 2022
Matthew Webb, Second Team, 2022
Ryan Dickson, Coach of the Year, 2022
